Main Differences Between Direct and Indirect Rapid Tooling

23 Sep.,2024

 

Main Differences Between Direct and Indirect Rapid Tooling

Tools or dies are significant in the manufacturing process. They are so important that in the global market, tooling alone has a revenue of around 60 billion dollars last year. The increase in automation like CNC machining has also paved the way for simple tools that are faster to make.

Check now

When there is a demand for production, tooling usually takes longer to make. This long lead time can cause a delay in the entire production process. The solution is going for rapid tooling. To maximize the benefits of this process, you need to choose the right rapid tooling type for your part.

There are two types of rapid tooling: direct and indirect. Both have their own set of pros and cons and the choice will depend on the requirements. In this article, we will provide the general differences between these two so that you can make a sound decision on which type to choose.

Direct vs Indirect Tooling

There are plenty of differences between direct and indirect rapid tooling. Aside from its difference, another factor that would determine the right rapid tooling method is knowing when to use them.

3D printed bridge prototypes is from blog.zmorph3d.com

Direct Rapid Tooling

Many attempts have been made to develop a new manufacturing technique that would reduce the lead times that has been a huge obstacle in the industry in the past. One approach is called direct tooling and the best example for this would be CNC machining.

With the use of CAD digital file, the direct tooling machine can chip off part from a block in a subtractive process. The newest addition to the direct tooling process is 3D printing, which is an additive process. It builds a 3D shape object by adding the materials layer by layer.

Wingtat Product Page

Both processes are frequently used in manufacturing and took less time to produce. These are the pros and cons of using direct rapid tooling:

Pros

  • Faster production
  • It involves fewer steps and resources to make
  • You can produce multiple prototypes
  • Flexible

Cons

  • Less durable
  • Prone to minor errors
  • Not suitable for complex designs
  • Increase in cost

Indirect Rapid Tooling

The second approach to rapid tooling is indirect tooling where the tool is formed using an intermediate step known as the &#;master&#; model. The master is a 3D shape which can be copied multiple times. The process may be retrogressive but it was proven effective. It ensures that the tools are strong and robust for high-volume production.

Pros

  • It makes durable tools
  • More cost-effective
  • You can create hard or soft tools depending on your requirement
  • It produces tools with less discrepancies and variations
  • You can use it to experiment with different materials

Cons

  • It is more time-consuming
  • Entails additional costs
  • It needs high quality materials to improve its durability
  • It does not fit simple designs and is more appropriate for complex designs

Key Takeaway

There you have it the major differences between direct and indirect tooling and its pros and cons. To choose the right rapid tooling solution, you need to evaluate your requirements and confer it with the pro-con list.

Rapid Prototyping: Advantages and Disadvantages

Many people get confused with rapid prototyping (here the word &#;prototype&#; means a model) and they confuse it with injection molding and others. But the rapid prototyping is a technology that is available to the designers so that with the help of it they can create a three-dimensional scale model of their designs. It can be any model with the design and shape of a cube, rectangular prism, sphere, cone, cylinder, etc., It is very helpful for engineers to create such models. Next, the technology that is used in the process of rapid prototyping is 3D printing, additive manufacturing systems, CNC machines, and injection-molding systems. Injection molding system is a part of the process due to which many get confused and think rapid prototyping is the same as injection molding. But it&#;s different in some aspects. 

Rapid Prototyping through CAD

In the process of Rapid prototyping, the system or the process which the engineer chooses depends on them and their design. In prototype models and products, CNC machines and injection moldings have also played a vital role in developing the same. In the rapid prototyping process, the model of any object is made using layer-by-layer CAD (computer-aided designs) models. Firstly, the designer of the model will create a 3D image or the model image in the computer, and then it will be connected with the prototyping machine. After setting the instructions, the models will be designed or created in the same way the image was created on the computer. 

Less Costly and Shorter Time

But again there is a complex process with the machines. The machines are pre-programmed. Besides that, there are four aspects in rapid prototyping that is input, materials, application, and method. Some of the advantages of rapid prototyping are as follows &#; It is one of the fastest methods for developing model ideas. Like you can create any 3D design and get the model. With the help of CAD, one can get multiple designs iterations. Rapid prototyping is like a CNC machine system in which the development time of the product is short and also the cost is reduced. Now, the cost factor depends on the number of models that you have ordered. If it&#;s 15 to 20 then it will be low cost. And if it&#;s 100 then the cost may increase, keeping the resources in view. 

No Material Wastage and Less Dust

Another benefit of the rapid prototyping method is that there is no material wastage like it is done in CNC machine work or rapid tooling. Along with the merits, there are some demerits also of the rapid prototyping system. One of the biggest demerits is shrinkage and thermal warping. Sometimes due to the size of the printer casing, there can be limitations in the size. One of the main reasons why rapid prototyping is very popular is because complicated designs can i.e. the difficult shapes can be easily built. Plus, there is less dust and waste. Just like a CNC machine, this machine also requires maintenance. In rapid prototyping, the machines and the software do the main work, so there is no need for any kind of human intervention.  

If you want to learn more, please visit our website Rapid Tooling For Injection Molding.

Guest Posts
*
*
* CAPTCHA
Submit